This is borderline but i'm always sick of new games being recorded with out a care that they might be too slow for the people who recording them's computers.

Here's the InpHist output from analinp and it shows Donuts single frame presses with very high percentage. I'm not qualified to tell if this is slowdown or not because i have no test case, but Ben might know more. This is just a yellow flag thrown on to the field by an in doubt official...

-------- InpHisto Report --------
Bit 12, length 1 : 75 ( 19.23%) 73 ( 23.86%) 2 ( 2.38%)
Bit 12, length 2 : 79 ( 20.26%) 73 ( 23.86%) 6 ( 7.14%)
Bit 12, length 3 : 81 ( 20.77%) 68 ( 22.22%) 13 ( 15.48%)
Bit 12, length 4 : 32 ( 8.21%) 25 ( 8.17%) 7 ( 8.33%)
Bit 12, length 5 : 20 ( 5.13%) 9 ( 2.94%) 11 ( 13.10%)
Bit 12, length 6 : 38 ( 9.74%) 21 ( 6.86%) 17 ( 20.24%)
Bit 12, length 7 : 14 ( 3.59%) 8 ( 2.61%) 6 ( 7.14%)
Bit 12, length 8 : 19 ( 4.87%) 11 ( 3.59%) 8 ( 9.52%)
Bit 12, length 9 : 22 ( 5.64%) 14 ( 4.58%) 8 ( 9.52%)
Bit 12, length 10 : 10 ( 2.56%) 4 ( 1.31%) 6 ( 7.14%)
Bit 12, length 11+ : 567 172 395
Bit 12, all lengths: 957 478 479
Bit 12, average lengths: 3.79 3.28 5.67
Bit 13, length 1 : 55 ( 18.21%) 52 ( 21.58%) 3 ( 4.92%)
Bit 13, length 2 : 84 ( 27.81%) 76 ( 31.54%) 8 ( 13.11%)
Bit 13, length 3 : 61 ( 20.20%) 53 ( 21.99%) 8 ( 13.11%)
Bit 13, length 4 : 17 ( 5.63%) 16 ( 6.64%) 1 ( 1.64%)
Bit 13, length 5 : 7 ( 2.32%) 4 ( 1.66%) 3 ( 4.92%)
Bit 13, length 6 : 21 ( 6.95%) 12 ( 4.98%) 9 ( 14.75%)
Bit 13, length 7 : 10 ( 3.31%) 7 ( 2.90%) 3 ( 4.92%)
Bit 13, length 8 : 12 ( 3.97%) 6 ( 2.49%) 6 ( 9.84%)
Bit 13, length 9 : 26 ( 8.61%) 12 ( 4.98%) 14 ( 22.95%)
Bit 13, length 10 : 9 ( 2.98%) 3 ( 1.24%) 6 ( 9.84%)
Bit 13, length 11+ : 505 162 343
Bit 13, all lengths: 807 403 404
Bit 13, average lengths: 3.73 3.13 6.08



-- Anonymous, January 25, 2001

Answers

It's wpc_pbobbl3j_78168930_m37b11.zip BTW.

-- Anonymous, January 25, 2001

I think Donut has a slow computer. Or, in other words: I give someone the benefit of the doubt until I have reason to believe someone cheated (as in using slowdown ON PURPOSE).

I have disqualified several of Donut's recordings in the past and his speed percentages during T4 showed illegal and barely legal speeds for his recordings.

I have my doubts about a lot of his recordings on MARP. The statistics seem to indicate slowdown, but not enough for disqualification in a lot of cases.

As for this particular one... around 40% of lengths 1 and 2 on one button and around 46% on another. I'd look at some other recordings, and if nobody else has this extremely high rate of lengths 1 and 2, then, yes, I'd disqualify it.

Again, I am not accusing Donut of cheating. But he should pay more attention to actually playing games at the correct speed.

Cheers, Ben Jos.

-- Anonymous, February 14, 2001